Accuracy of Canada’s housing data under scrutiny
Canada’s surprisingly strong real estate market is leading to heightened scrutiny of the data used to assess sales.
The main source of information about residential sales and prices is the Canadian Real Estate Association, which represents more than 100,000 real estate agents across the country. On or around the 15th day of each month, after obtaining and working with numbers from local real estate boards, CREA releases information about the previous month’s sales levels.
The numbers are getting more attention amid debate about just how inflated the market may be. Nearly all economists agreed that house prices were too high when Finance Minister Jim Flaherty stepped in and tightened mortgage insurance rules in July, 2012. Sales dropped, diminishing talk of any potential bubble as the market slumped for nearly a year. In recent months, it has bounced back, and topped economists’ expectations.
It appears that the number of houses changing hands this year will exceed last year’s total. But most experts say the strength is unlikely to last long, and the market should cool a bit as higher mortgage rates trickle through the system.
As people try to make sense of the market’s twists and turns, some are raising questions about the accuracy of CREA’s statistics. One of the main critics is former Member of Parliament and blogger Garth Turner, who has recently been calling CREA’s numbers into question on his blog. He alleged, among other things, that the numbers are being distorted by real estate agents listing one house with two or three local real estate boards (so more buyers will see the listing).
Mr. Turner’s skepticism caught the attention of other analysts. “I must confess that it was a blog by Garth Turner that kind of raised that issue,” said Douglas Porter, Bank of Montreal’s chief economist. “I found it fascinating.”
“You do have to look at [the numbers] through the lens of where they’re coming from but just like any other economic data, I don’t think any single number should be treated as the final gospel,” Mr. Porter said. “There is a margin for error around every economic statistic, and we take it with a grain of salt, but I think the CREA numbers do a good job of capturing the trend.”
CREA chief economist Gregory Klump said that just because a listing appears more than once online, does not mean it is included more than once in the statistics. “The fact is, Realtor.ca is not the basis on which we do our statistics,” he said, referring to CREA’s website. “Just because something is duplicately listed on Realtor.ca doesn’t mean that it’s duplicately counted in sales and in active listings.”
Read More @ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/
Listings for Mon Oct 28
Open Map
C2764463 – M4S – 293 BALLIOL ST Toronto, Ontario – $ 799,000
Price Change. Oct 28: $ 799,000 Oct 17: $ 815,000
Stroll To Chic Yonge & St Clair And Shopping, Dining & Cultural Venues From Davisville Village! Contemporary Urban Stylish Total Reno On 3 Levels. …
C2772041 – M5V – 422 LAKE SHORE BLVD W Toronto, Ontario – $ 968,000
Magnificent Building In Downtown Toronto,Incredible Opportunity To Work And Live In New 2 Storey Condo Townhouse Right At Water Front, Minutes From Cn …
C2772062 – M3C – 89 SOUTHILL DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 439,000
Lovely Renovated 2 Storey 3 Bedroom / 2 Bathroom Condo Townhouse In The Heart Of Don Mills. Hardwood Floors Throughout. Renovated Kitchen And Bathroom. …
C2772147 – M3H – 757 SHEPPARD AVE W Toronto, Ontario – $ 659,900
Steps To The Downsview Subway, 2600 Sq.Ft Of Living Space (With Only $ 700 A Year Landscaping Fee)Custom Built Wall-To-Wall …
E2728631 – M1E – 351 MILITARY TR Toronto, Ontario – $ 268,000
Price Change. Oct 28: $ 268,000 Sep 24: $ 272,000
Bright & Spacious Townhome In The Seven Oak Area!!! Immaculate 4 Bedrms With Open Concept And Finished Basement. Upgraded Laminate Flooring In The Main …
E2745282 – M1E – 154 CELESTE DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 339,500
Price Change. Oct 28: $ 339,500 Sep 24: $ 342,500
Gorgeous Family Home,Beautiful 3 Bedroom Semi-Detached On Large Lot In A Fabulous Neighbourhood In High Demand Area.Renovated Hardwood All Thru-Out …
E2772105 – M1G – 31 FIRTH CRES Toronto, Ontario – $ 429,000
Upgraded 3 Bdrm. Home On Quiet Street. Modern Kitchen, Stone, Granite, Pot Lights, Hardwood,37Stainless Appliances, Bright …
E2772118 – M1E – 189 GALLOWAY RD Toronto, Ontario – $ 229,000
Beautiful Stacked 3 Story Townhouse Perfect For First Time Buyers Or Small Family; Open Concept Layout With Picture Windows; Quiet Complex With …
E2772124 – M1G – 49 THORNBECK DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 359,900
Spacious Home, Open Concept Main Floor, Kitchen With Breakfast …
W2723187 – M8Z – 1050 THE QUEENSWAY AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 244,500
Price Change. Oct 28: $ 244,500 Sep 24: $ 249,900
Immaculate! Stunning Unit!! Open Concept, Upgraded Kitchen With Granite Counter Tops, Backsplash, Spicer Cabinet, Glass …
W2756240 – M6R – 164 SUNNYSIDE AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 975,000
Price Change. Oct 5: $ 1,199,000 Oct 28: $ 975,000
Beautiful Legal Triplex With Basement Apartment. Bright Units With Natural Light. Owner Occupied Vacant …
W2764728 – M9C – 12 ARDUA ST Toronto, Ontario – $ 729,000
Price Change. Oct 28: $ 729,000 Oct 18: $ 819,000
Absolutely Charming & Elegant 4 Level Stucco/Brick Backsplit W/Double Garage Situated On A Quiet Cul-De-Sac.Rarely Offered.This 3+1 Bdrm Home Has Many …
W2771082 – M9V – 162 THISTLEDOWN BLVD Toronto, Ontario – $ 419,900
Price Change. Oct 26: $ 399,900 Oct 28: $ 419,900
Handyman Or Woman s Delight! This Well Loved 4 Bedroom4 Level Backsplit Is Spacious And Needs Updating. The Original 1950 Eat-In Kitchen, 2 Bathrooms, …
W2772080 – M9M – 63 LINDY LOU RD Toronto, Ontario – $ 469,900
Wow!!!, Fully Renovated Upstairs, New Kitchen, New Wshrms, New Paint, New Ceramics, Fully Living, Dining And Kitchen Open Concept, Pot Lights, New …
W2772140 – M3N – 56 TOBERMORY DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 479,000
Beautiful 115 Ft Wide Detached House, Frnting On South.Corner Lot.Located In Mature,Quiet Dead-End Street.Newly Painted.Refinished H/W Flr.Professional …
Whaddaya Say?