Could be good ? Maybe bad ?
By Don Pittis, CBC News
Don Pittis has been a Fuller Brush man, a forest fire fighter and an Arctic ranger before discovering journalism. He was principal business reporter for Radio Television Hong Kong before the handover to China and has produced and reported for CBC and BBC News. He is currently senior producer at CBC’s business unit.
Rule No. 1: A property bubble isn’t a bubble till it pops. Whether it’s Shanghai, London, or Toronto, until the final blow-up, it’s just a rising market driven by rising demand.
Just ask the people who sell real estate. They will tell you we are nowhere near a bubble. And lately we’ve seen a number of opinion pieces by what you might call “bubble scoffers,” who are reacting to the loose use of the term that ascribes bubble characteristics to everything from bitcoins to stocks to the boom in technology start-ups.
My own prescription to prevent a bubble, a wider sense of caution, which I offered more than a year ago, still stands.
But as 2013 comes to an end, rather than join either the chorus of warnings or those of reassurance, I thought that in the spirit of the season, I would take a different stance altogether. I would like to look on the bright side. Certainly, we need some optimism.
Reason for hope
We’ve had another year of foreboding on global property prices from very respectable sources. New homes in big Chinese cities are up another 20 per cent despite attempts by the government to cool the market. In London, prices are rising at six times the rate of inflation.
Even Mark Carney, the Canadian-born head of the Bank of England, can’t keep a lid on it. Canada comes in for special treatment. The latest of the doomsayers, Deutsche Bank, said in a Scrooge-like pre-Christmas superlative that Canadian property was the most overvalued on the planet — some 60 per cent above what it should be. Just in November it was the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development — the rich countries think tank — that singled out Canada’s property market for a potential “disorderly correction.”
Where are we now ?
Economist Jean-Paul Rodrigue came up with this visualization for how most asset bubbles proceed. (Courtesy Jean-Paul Rodrigue)That sounds worrying, but it’s actually a euphemism for something even uglier. Instead of dwelling on how much many of us — and me in particular — would lose if we had a 60 per cent correction in the Canadian property market, I thought it best to don my rose-coloured glasses and borrow from the subtitle of one of my favourite movies, Dr. Strangelove.
The theme for this holiday season bedtime story is: “Why I learned to stop worrying and love the property bubble.” Occasionally in economics, a rising tide raises all boats. But often it’s a lot more choppy. There are winners and losers.
‘Occasionally in economics, a rising tide raises all boats. But often it’s a lot more choppy. There are winners and losers.’– Don Pittis
To the economist, observing economic cycles is like the kid gazing at waves rolling in on a beach and thinking about the forces causing their repetition and patterns. The stock trader is like the other kid on the beach who thinks she has it figured out, wades in and keeps getting her good shoes wet.
So long as you don’t care about the exact moment of a peak or trough, watching economic cycles can teach you many useful things. One of the things they tell you is that the supply of new houses created by the economy does not grow in exact proportion to the growing number of households.
Peaks and valleys
Sometimes, the peaks of ocean waves are well above sea level. Sometimes the troughs are well below. The same things happen with the supply of houses. What causes the peaks and troughs in house construction is sometimes mysterious. But as someone old enough to have watched many little waves and at least three big ones, it is interesting how at the end of every big cycle, there is a glut of houses.
I remember the end of the “townhouse” boom as a kid. Townhouses went cheap and construction projects stalled unfinished. I remember two houses in Toronto’s now-pricey South Kingsway neighbourhood standing uncompleted for years afterwards.
These booms followed by busts are not a uniquely Canadian phenomenon. Pictures of luxury houses surrounded by weeds are a symbol of the end of the U.S. boom in 2008. More recently, property busts hit Ireland and Spain. The subject has been well studied. As this report from the European Central Bank shows, just about every industrialized economy goes through the cycle.
As the report also shows, while Germany gets credit for low rents and a stable property market since 2008, it is no coincidence that as of 2007, the country had just gone through a seven-year property bust. Because that’s what happens after an excessive boom.
As the famous graph from Canadian economic geographer Jean-Paul Rodrigue shows, after a bubble pops, valuations plunge with demand to a level well below the average expected price levels. We have seen the same thing in oil, natural gas, gold, potash.
High prices push up production, followed by a point when too much is being produced and prices fall. In the housing market, where the construction cycle of a single building can take at least two years and the product lasts decades, it is not so easy to turn off the tap. Market economists often complain that rent and price controls distort the market for property because underpricing fails to instruct the market to produce enough.
But the factors the ECB blames for inciting a boom — “including short-term interest rates, local and global money and credit developments, and the incidence of mortgage market deregulation” — can also distort a market the other way, producing too much.
And this, finally, is the good thing about a property bubble. While you may suffer personally when the price of your house falls, and while the wider economy may suffer a contraction when homeowners suddenly feel poor, the greater Canadian economy will benefit.
Here’s why: During bubbles, a country grows its housing stock, over-investing in the construction of new properties so that the supply is more than sufficient, allowing prices to fall relative to income. At the end of a bubble, finally and for quite a while afterwards, there is enough to go round.
Reason for optimism
As the ECB report says, “there has been a strong correlation between the persistence and magnitude of booms and of subsequent busts.” And that’s why, when I take a long view through my rose-coloured glasses, I feel good when I see signs for new luxury homes and condos. That’s why there should be no restriction on building them.
Luxury homes are well made and made to last. Just like the bedraggled mansions in older parts of town I remember as I was growing up, luxury housing may not stay luxurious forever, but it contributes valuable housing stock during the downward part of the cycle.
What Canada is experiencing now may or may not be a bubble. Today, I promised to be agnostic on that point. If this is not a bubble, then we are producing just the right amount of housing to supply our needs and we can keep on doing that forever. Prices in the new paradigm will stay at the current permanently high plateau.
If it is a bubble, unfortunately for those who want to buy low and sell high, we have no idea how long it might last. Remember rule No. 1. But if you do hear the pop, think of it as a champagne cork celebrating a new era of property stability.
Excellent commentary …
All the best for 2014.
Read More @ CBC News
Listings for Sat Jan 4
Open Map
C2738568 – M2J – 71 BLOORVIEW PL Toronto, Ontario – $ 1,149,000
Price Change. Jan 4: $ 1,149,000 Nov 5: $ 1,179,000 Sep 24: $ 1,250,000
New! Never Lived In Townhome. Desireable Tenor End Unit. W/ Access To Aria Condo s First Class Amenities. $ $ Spent On Upgrades Incl Quartz Counter …
C2788933 – – $ 7,990,000
Price Change. Nov 22: $ 6,999,000 Jan 4: $ 7,990,000
Location, Location, Prestigious Bridle Path Estate. Backing Onto Ravine Of Edward Garden, Contemporary Flair, Graceful Flow, Perfect …
C2804634 – M3H – 225 MAXWELL ST Toronto, Ontario – $ 1,299,000
Show With Proud,No Comparables!Luxurious Living At It s Best. Apprx 4450 Sq.Ft.Plus Finished W/O Bsmnt With 9 F Ceiling. Resort-Style Ravine Lot In Prime …
C2804636 – M2J – 7 CHERYL SHEPWAY WAY Toronto, Ontario – $ 475,000
Location! 2 Storey With W/O Basement 3 Bedrooms Townhouse!! The Last Oasis Along The Sheppard Subway!! Quietest Location In Complex!! Steps To …
C2804674 – M2M – 42 MINTWOOD DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 679,900
*Rarely Offered,One Of The Lrgst 2 Storey Semi s Across From The Ravine In Prestigious Bayview Woods, Including Private Drive & Dble Car Garage! …
C2804754 – M3N – 728 CONACHER DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 1,399,000
…
C2804780 – M2K – 3 REAN DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 619,900
Great Prestige Location!Just Opposite To The Bayview Village,Near Subway And Easy Access To Hwy401 & Dvp.Stunning Beautiful Unit,Strip Hrdwd Floor …
C2804845 – M2N – 196 HOLMES AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 2,238,800
Spectacular New Custom Blt Home On Wide Lot: 53 Feet Frontage!Elegantly Designed W/Superb Craftsmanship**Tarion Warranty**Large Liv&Din Rm,Gourmet Kit …
C2804863 – M2R – 47 TERRACE AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 1,388,888
Magnificent Custom Built Home In The Desirable Willowdale West Neighborhood .This Stunning Home Offers Lrg Lvng&Dng W/Bay Wndws.Large Open Concept Kit …
C2804916 – – $ 849,900
Unique Opportunity! / Spacious & Bright Bungalow In Prime Central Location / Upgrades Include: Kitchens, Baths, Basement, Floors ++/ …
C2804919 – M6C – 2B CROYDON RD Toronto, Ontario – $ 999,000
Live/Work Lifestyle. Built New In 2012. Architect s Home/Workspace. 4 Lvls Live/Work Form Factor. Cool Functional Design For Downsizing Boomers And …
C2804970 – M5N – 287 STRATHALLAN WOOD Toronto, Ontario – $ 1,249,000
Custom Executive Home / 4+1 Bdrms, 4 Baths / Quality Finishes Thruout / Combined Living-Dining Room Ideal For …
C2805053 – M5M – 545 DOUGLAS AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 1,095,000
46 Ft Lot, Great For Investor Or Family Looking For A Well-Built Home. Close To Grocery, Schools, Shopping & Places Of Worship. Cozy Home In An Amazing …
E2783709 – M4J – 373 JONES AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 699,000
Price Change. Jan 4: $ 699,000 Dec 5: $ 759,000 Nov 14: $ 799,000
Detached Bright House With Detached Double Garage. Renovated From Top To Bottom And …
E2798226 – M1K – 59 MOOREGATE AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 530,000
Price Change. Jan 4: $ 530,000 Dec 10: $ 540,000
Exquisite Interior Meticulously Maintained By Two Previous Owners. Beautiful Curb Appeal Complimented By An Award Winning Professionally Landscaped Front …
E2801706 – M1V – 75 MCCOOL CRT Toronto, Ontario – $ 458,000
Price Change. Dec 19: $ 398,000 Jan 4: $ 458,000 Dec 31: $ 489,000
**Stunning Well-Kept House Located On Prime Steeles/Midland Location**Totally Renovated**Gleaming Hardwood Floor Thru-Out**Gourmet Kitchen W/Breakfast …
E2804567 – M4K – 24 DARTFORD RD Toronto, Ontario – $ 478,800
Unique Home In Playter Estates A Five Minute Walk To Broadview Subway Station, Danforth Shops And Schools In The Jackman School District. Minutes To …
E2804578 – M1V – 163 CAROLBREEN SQ Toronto, Ontario – $ 439,000
Immaculate & Spacious 3-Bedroom Freehold Townhome In High Demand Area In Scarborough. Gleaming Hardwood Floor In Living Room & Dinning Room (Hardwood …
E2804657 – M1B – 42 PINERY TR Toronto, Ontario – $ 238,000
37Spacious 3 Bedroom And 2 Full Bathrooms, Beautiful End Unit Condo Townhouse In Desired Community; Lots Of Upgrade ,Very Bright, Beautiful Park View. …
E2804708 – M1E – 40 MORNING DEW RD Toronto, Ontario – $ 415,000
Beautiful Newly Updated 3 Bed 2 Bath Bungalow In The Heart Of The West Hill Community!! Steps To The Ttc And Minutes From Highland Creek Park, Guildwood …
E2804717 – M1E – 405 BEECHGROVE DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 309,990
Jasper Model-2 Br, High Quality Finished.Close To Transportation, 401,Parks & Conservation Area. Also …
E2804742 – M1E – 405 BEECHGROVE DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 349,990
Redwood Model. 2Br +Den. High Quality Finished. Close To Transportation, 401, Park & Conservation Area, Also University Of …
E2804759 – M1E – 389 BEECHGROVE DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 289,990
Hyde Model – 2 Br + Den, Quality Finished, Close To Transportation & Hwy 401. Backs Onto Park And Conservation Area. …
E2804812 – M1B – 50 BLACKWELL AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 309,000
See The Realtor Website For Additional Information, Pictures And Virtual Tour For This Listing. You Will Need To Enter The Mls Number E2804812 In The …
E2804928 – M4E – 22 FAIRHEAD MEWS Toronto, Ontario – $ 528,800
Stunning Freehold Townhome In The Heart Of The Upper Beach! Large End Unit Offers A Bright, Open Concept Main Level With S/S Appliances, Granite …
E2804960 – M1T – 3847 FINCH AVE E Toronto, Ontario – $ 579,000
Great Opportunity To Own A Great Investment Property On Finch Ave. High Demanding Kennedy & Finch Agincourt Location. Steps To Ttc, Mall …
E2805011 – M1W – 142 BROOKMILL BLVD Toronto, Ontario – $ 499,900
An Up Graded Lovely Home! Modern White Kit.W/Added Pantry + Pots & Pan Drawer, New Counter,37 Dbl Sink & Moen Faucet, Large Eat In Area! Huge Liv & L …
E2805021 – – $ 659,000
Ground Fl & Bsmt Is Being Used As A Dental Office W/1 Reception Area, 1 Office, 2 Treatment Rooms(One Rough In), Can Be Converted Back Into Lr, Dr, …
E2805024 – M1B – 232 ROUGE RIVER DR Toronto, Ontario – $ 369,900
Outstanding Freehold Townhouse In Sought After Area! Legendary ?mattamy? Open-Concept Floor Plan Freshly Painted In Neutral Tones To Accent The Natural …
W2770549 – M9A – 47 EDENVALE CRES Toronto, Ontario – $ 1,899,000
Price Change. Jan 4: $ 1,899,000 Oct 25: $ 1,980,000
Most Dynamic Residential Opportunity In Prime Etobicoke. Custom Built Italian Home. 3444 Sq Ft Plus 2343 Sq Ft Lower Level. Total Of 6287 Sqft. …
W2787555 – M9V – 2901 KIPLING AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 118,900
Price Change. Jan 4: $ 118,900 Nov 28: $ 119,900 Nov 26: $ 124,900 Nov 23: $ 129,000 Nov 20: $ 131,900
Great Value: Truly Gorgeous & Spacious Unit In A Luxury Building. Renovated. New Ceramic …
W2804579 – M9A – 30 SIR WILLIAMS LANE Toronto, Ontario – $ 1,995,000
Rare Opportunity In Prestigious Thorncrest Village – Large Bungalow In Park Like …
W2804625 – M6E – 412 GILBERT AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 474,900
Great Opportunity For Builders/Investors…. 2 Bedroom Detached Bungalow On A Deep Lot …… …
W2804635 – M9N – 234 PELLATT AVE Toronto, Ontario – $ 439,000
Large Detached Family Home Located Near Parks, Ttc, Hwy And …
W2804732 – M9B – 2 VALHALLA INN RD Toronto, Ontario – $ 269,900
. **** EXTRAS **** Stove, Fridge, …
W2804781 – M9N – 152 CHURCH ST Toronto, Ontario – $ 769,000
**Custom Built, Italian Style Home, Approx 300 Sqft** **Premium 50 Ft Lot, In Ground Sprinklers, Floating Open Riser Staircase, Rare Full Bathroom On …